Watch on YouTube (and Subscribe while you are there!)
Jordan is joined by the live feed correspondents (Alex Kidwell, Taran Armstrong, and Brent Wolgamott) to attempt to predict what Big Brother 18 would look like if it’s an all returning player season. Each submitted a list of 12 males and 12 females they believe CBS would call to come play again, with corresponding point values based on how high they were ranked. Alex then used the associated point values to put together a list of 16 houseguests and two alternates that could be seen this summer. Players who appear to have other commitments this summer, were not included in the rankings (even if CBS would hypothetically want them on the show).
| FINAL CAST | MALE | FEMALE |
| #1 | Frank Eudy (14) – 37 | Vanessa Rousso (17) – 47 |
| #2 | Frankie Grande (16) – 36 | Da’Vonne Rogers (17) – 32 |
| #3 | Donny Thompson (16) – 31 | Amanda Zuckerman (15) – 29 |
| #4 | John McGuire (17) – 26 | Danielle Reyes (3/7) – 27 |
| #5 | James Huling (17) – 22 | Audrey Middleton (17) – 26 |
| #6 | Ian Terry (14) – 19 | Daniele Donato (8/13) – 24 |
| #7 | Zach Rance (16) – 16 | *Nicole Franzel (16) – 23 |
| #8 | *Cody Calafiore (16) – 14 | *Janelle Pierzina (6/7/14) – 23 |
| Alt. | *Eric Stein (8) – 14 | Michelle Costa (10) – 15 |
| HON. MENTION | ALEX | BRENT | JORDAN | TARAN |
| MALE | Dr. Will Kirby (2/7) | Jessie Godderz (10, 11) | Andy Herren (15) | Matt Hoffman (12) |
| FEMALE | Helen Kim (15) | Kalia Booker (13) | Britney Godwin (12, 14) | Jen Johnson (8) |
| MALE | ALEX | BRENT | JORDAN | TARAN |
| #1 | Dr. Will Kirby (2/7) | Frank Eudy (14) | John McGuire (17) | Donny Thompson (16) |
| #2 | Derrick Levasseur (16) | Eric Stein (8) | Donny Thompson (16) | Frankie Grande (16) |
| #3 | Mike “Boogie” Malin (2/7/14) | Ian Terry (14) | James Huling (17) | Frank Eudy (14) |
| #4 | Frankie Grande (16) | Matt Hoffman (12) | Frank Eudy (14) | Cody Calafiore (16) |
| #5 | Donny Thompson (16) | Frankie Grande (16) | Frankie Grande (16) | James Huling (17) |
| #6 | John McGuire (17) | Brian Hart (10) | Zach Rance (16) | John McGuire (17) |
| #7 | Frank Eudy (14) | Jessie Godderz (10) | Ian Terry (14) | Enzo Palumbo (12) |
| #8 | Zach Rance (16) | Kaysar Ridha (6) | Andy Herren (15) | Austin Matelson (17) |
| #9 | James Huling (17) | Enzo Palumbo (11) | Cody Calafiore (16) | Zach Rance (16) |
| #10 | Ian Terry (14) | Dominic Briones (13) | McCrae Olson (15) | Eric Stein (8) |
| #11 | Andy Herren (15) | Hayden Voss (16) | Enzo Palumbo (12) | Matt Hoffman (12) |
| #12 | Cody Calafiore (16) | Will Wikle (5) | Mike “Boogie” Malin (2,7,14) | McCrae Olson (15) |
| FEMALE | ALEX | BRENT | JORDAN | TARAN |
| #1 | Vanessa Rousso (17) | Michelle Costa (10) | Vanessa Rousso (17) | Vanessa Rousso (17) |
| #2 | Danielle Reyes (3/7) | Vanessa Rousso (17) | Nicole Franzel (16) | Daniele Donato (8,13) |
| #3 | Janelle Pierzina (6/7/14) | Kalia Booker (13) | Amanda Zuckerman (15) | Danielle Reyes (3,7) |
| #4 | Britney Godwin (12/14) | Keesha Smith (10) | Da’Vonne Rogers (17) | Da’Vonne Rogers (17) |
| #5 | Amanda Zuckerman (15) | Janelle Pierzina (6) | Audrey Middleton (17) | Audrey Middleton (17) |
| #6 | Da’Vonne Rogers (17) | Da’Vonne Rogers (17) | Daniele Donato (8,13) | Nicole Franzel (16) |
| #7 | Daniele Donato (8/13) | Audrey Middleton (17) | Danielle Reyes (3,7) | Amanda Zuckerman (15) |
| #8 | Nicole Franzel (16) | Amanda Zuckerman (15) | Janelle Pierzina (6, 7, 14) | Jen Johnson (8) |
| #9 | Audrey Middleton (17) | Jen Johnson (8) | Britney Godwin (12, 14) | Shelly Moore (13) |
| #10 | Helen Kim (15) | Danielle Murphree (14) | Meg Maley (17) | Michelle Costa (10) |
| #11 | Jackie Ibarra (17) | Annie Whittington (12) | Jackie Ibarra (17) | Helen Kim (15) |
| #12 | Shelly Moore (13) | Libra Thompson (10) | Shelly Moore (13) | Renny Martyn (10) |
