Jordan is once again joined by Alex Kidwell, Brent Wolgamott and Taran Armstrong to rank the winners of Big Brother US. For the sake of this ranking, Eddie McGee (the winner of Big Brother 1), was not included because of the difference in format. Each person ranked winners from 1 to 16 in terms of who they think is the best player, not necessarily who they think had the best winning game.
Here’s a link to the panel’s full set of individual rankings, as well as the final rankings after being averaged out (and debated on the podcast):
| ALEX | BRENT | JORDAN | TARAN | |
| #1 | Will Kirby (2) | Derrick LeVasseur (16) | Will Kirby (2) | Dan Gheesling (10) |
| #2 | Dan Gheesling (10) | Andy Herren (15) | Dan Gheesling (10) | Will Kirby (2) |
| #3 | Derrick LeVasseur (16) | Dan Gheesling (10) | Derrick LeVasseur (16) | Derrick LaVasseur (16) |
| #4 | Andy Herren (15) | Will Kirby (2) | Mike “Boogie” Malin (7) | Andy Herren (15) |
| #5 | Jun Song (4) | Maggie Ausburn (6) | Andy Herren (15) | Hayden Moss (12) |
| #6 | Mike “Boogie” Malin (7) | Steve Moses (17) | Hayden Moss (12) | Maggie Ausburn (6) |
| #7 | Hayden Moss (12) | Adam Jasinski (9) | Maggie Ausburn (6) | Mike “Boogie” Malin (7) |
| #8 | Maggie Ausburn (6) | Jun Song (4) | Lisa Donahue (3) | Jun Song (4) |
| #9 | Drew Daniel (5) | Hayden Moss (12) | Drew Daniel (5) | Steve Moses (17) |
| #10 | Lisa Donahue (3) | Lisa Donahue (3) | Jun Song (4) | Lisa Donahue (3) |
| #11 | Ian Terry (14) | Ian Terry (14) | Evel Dick Donato (8) | Drew Daniel (5) |
| #12 | Steve Moses (17) | Rachel Reilly (13) | Ian Terry (14) | Ian Terry (14) |
| #13 | Evel Dick Donato (8) | Drew Daniel (5) | Steve Moses (17) | Adam Jasinski (9) |
| #14 | Rachel Reilly (13) | Mike ‘Boogie’ Malin (7) | Adam Jasinski (9) | Evel Dick Donato (8) |
| #15 | Adam Jasinski (9) | Evel Dick Donato (15) | Rachel Reilly (13) | Jordan Lloyd (11) |
| #16 | Jordan Lloyd (11) | Jordan Lloyd (11) | Jordan Lloyd (11) | Rachel Reilly (13) |
| AVERAGE RANK | CONSENSUS RANK | |||
| Will Kirby (2) | 2* | #1 Tie – Will Kirby (2.0) | ||
| Lisa Donahue (3) | 9.5* | #1 Tie – Dan Gheesling (2.0) | ||
| Jun Song (4) | 7.75* | #3 – Derrick LeVasseur (2.5) | ||
| Drew Daniel (5) | 11* | #4 – Andy Herren (3.75) | ||
| Maggie Ausburn (6) | 6.5* | #5 – Maggie Ausburn (6.0) | ||
| Mike “Boogie” Malin (7) | 7.75* | #6 – Hayden Moss (6.75) | ||
| Evel Dick Donato (8) | 13.25* | #7 Tie – Mike “Boogie” Malin (7.75) | ||
| Adam Jasinski (9) | 12.25* | #7 Tie – Jun Song (7.75) | ||
| Dan Gheesling (10) | 2* | #9 – Lisa Donahue (9.5) | ||
| Jordan Lloyd (11) | 15.75* | #10 – Steve Moses (10.0) | ||
| Hayden Moss (12) | 6.75* | #11 – Drew Daniel (10.5) | ||
| Rachel Reilly (13) | 14* | #12 – Ian Terry (11.5) | ||
| Ian Terry (14) | 11.5* | #13 – Adam Jasinski (12.25) | ||
| Andy Herren (15) | 3.75* | #14 – Evel Dick Donato (13.25) | ||
| Derrick LeVasseur (16) | 2.5* | #15 – Rachel Reilly (14.25) | ||
| Steve Moses (17) | 10* | #16 – Jordan Lloyd (15.75) |
