Our favorite Final 2, the Survivor Know-It-Alls are back! Rob and Stephen recap the losses of Lindsey Ogle and Alexis Maxwell in Episode 5 of Survivor Cagayan.
Rob and Stephen discuss whether getting rid of Alexis was the right move for Aparri. Stephen notes that Alexis was too giddy to see that her alliance, Jefra and LJ, were still in the game. Rob says Alexis tried to jump ship even last episode. Stephen thinks a hot girl being strategic really throws people for a loop. Rob said Alexis is not a great social player even though she understands Survivor strategy. Rob and Stephen comment that Alexis and Lindsey were two bookends who went out of the game with similar emotions but for very different reasons.
The Know-It-Alls think that Aparri made the right move because Alexis is more dangerous than Jeremiah and she would definitely flip back to the beauties and go far into the game. It’s also in their best interest to keep Jeremiah in case there’s another challenge.
Rob and Stephen discuss Lindsey Ogle quitting the game and her interaction with Trish Hegarty. Stephen thinks Lindsey will regret this decision and Rob thinks that she is stubborn in her choices. Rob says that there is a lot that we didn’t see because typically Survivor production makes it very difficult to quit. Rob says that this quit is pretty bad, but not as bad as Naonka and Purple Kelly. Stephen thinks that Lindsey may be worse because it didn’t even have anything to do with the elements.
Tony makes history by being the first person to win a Fishy and a Cesty in the same moment. The Know-It-Alls think it was a major Tony win that he got out Cliff and Lindsey with one move. Rob notes that Tony definitely has his idol at the Salana camp. They both commend Tony’s clever move to trick Jeremiah, even though Jeremiah figured him out. They definitely do not commend his move to tell everyone about his lies.
Rob and Stephen also think that Woo has been doing a great job. They also are surprised that Morgan and Sarah have made it through unscathed.
To RHAP up the show, Rob and Stephen answer your many questions about tonight’s episode: should Sarah swing to the Appari tribe or the Salana tribe? Was Tony trying to save Sarah? What is going to happen with the immunity idols? Is Spencer being too transparent? What was the right move for Jeremiah? Who are the floaters?
Remember to check out Hulu+ for old Survivor episodes and current shows – sign up at www.huluplus.com/rob and get two weeks free.
Stay tuned over the next few days for Rob’s interviews with Lindsey, Alexis, and Marty Piombo!
Special Thanks to Taylor Cotter for Recapping Tonight’s Show