Survivor: Ghost Island

Survivor: Ghost Island Power Rankings—Week 3 with Melissa Deni

Matt Liguori ranks the players each week with a new guest in RHAP’s Survivor Power Rankings. This week Matt is joined by RHAP Big Brother Live Feed Correspondent, Melissa Deni!

  • Note: If reading on a cell phone, rotate your device horizontally to read the rankings side-by-side. However, this may not work for some devices with smaller screens.

Survivor: Ghost Island Week 3 Power Rankings

I’m not off to the greatest start this season with these ol’ predictions. I’ll blame it on the fact that there are approximately 37 reality shows all airing at once right now. Survivor, Challenge, Big Brother, Drag Race, Bachelor, Idol, etc. etc. etc. I go to sleep at night hoping Shangela doesn’t vote to evict Cara Maria if Domenick pulls out his immunity idol when Arie gives his final rose to Paras. I know, I need so much help.

I had Brendan pegged as pretty safe last week until that came crashing down right in my face. I thought the play from Michael was about as well executed as it could get. That four really got screwed by the Ghost Island exile (Kellyn this week) coming back in time for the vote, which hadn’t been a thing up until this point. Oh well. We’ll be down to 15 after this week’s tribal council, so I’m keeping my fingers crossed for another swap into 3 tribes to keep things interesting.

I’ve got another great guest with me this week. Taking a small break from the Big Brother Canada 6 coverage, it’s the peace keeper of the LFC, Melissa Deni! Melissa is holding it down in her Survivor draft with the other LFC members, with up-and-coming strategic queens Desiree and Chelsea headlining her team also including Wendell, Bradley, Jenna, and the now-departed Brendan. If you missed that draft, it’s not too late to check it out (here), and make sure you’ve been plugged into all of the BBCAN6 content if you’re following the season. Follow Melissa with three As (@itsmelissaaa) and I (@mattliguori) on twitter, tweet us to let us know what you think and/or leave a comment below!

sgibar

matt_sgi

Matt

melissa_sgi

Melissa


laurel

1. Laurel
green-arrow2

I’m thrilled we finally got to see Laurel explain where her head’s at. Her options are wide open, with everybody on her tribe looking to work with her. Should be smooth sailing for a bit.

laurel

1. Laurel

Laurel had a great episode this week. She got to tell some of her story, she played a major role in determining the direction of her tribe, and she made some new allies. I’m excited to see where this takes her next week.


donathan

2. Donathan
green-arrow2

Still working with the Malolos, Donathan has nothing to worry about until the game next shakes up. The farther we get, the less of a target he’s seen as and the more dangerous he becomes.

kellyn

2. Kellyn

Kellyn made the correct, albeit totally boring, choice on Ghost Island when she decided not to rock the boat and keep the numbers the same. She’s in the majority and while she’s not blending into the woodwork by any means, she’s also not sticking out like a sore thumb like Bradley. Also, people don’t hate her… unlike Bradley.


kellyn

3. Kellyn
red-arrow2

Having the Survivor gods already going against your wishes isn’t a great sign! Kellyn has her group of five who proved last week is a strong voting block and that should keep her safe for now. I was initially a little annoyed when she didn’t play the game, but it’s pretty clear she made the right call.

james

3. James

James had a good week last week and stayed pretty far under the radar this week, which really isn’t a bad thing in his case!


sebastian

4. Sea Bass
green-arrow2

Tempted to rank this guy at the bottom simply because he didn’t talk about candy this week… which means his storyline is obviously over and he’s the next to go.

libby

4. Libby

Libby is a lot more of a threat than I gave her credit for pre-season. While she was barely seen this week (…did I even see her?), she’s in a good position on her tribe.


james

5. James
red-arrow4

We didn’t hear much from James this week, but I think it’s fair to assume he and Laurel are still super tight. For his sake I hope so, because I do think Laurel is in the best position on their tribe at the moment.

donathan

5. Donathan

Laurel and Donathan were the determining factors in siding with Wendell and Domenick, which I think was a smart move. If he and Laurel can stay strong, I can see them going really far as a pair.


libby

6. Libby
red-arrow1

A quiet week for Libby too. I don’t remember one instance of seeing her in the episode, but since her alliance is still in control, I’m not worried.

wendell

6. Wendell

Things are looking a lot better for Wendell this week. Not to mention the fact that EVERYONE on the tribe said that they liked him. Superior social game can carry you pretty far.


desiree

7. Desiree
green-arrow7

Oooof. Desiree finally gets to a Tribal and still barely gets to talk? She was obviously in with the group’s planning/decision making. She was the one we first saw throwing out Brendan’s name. I still need more from Desiree to know where her game is heading, but right now she’s looking safe.

chelsea

7. Chelsea

She speaks!! Finally! And not only does she speak, but she actually has good things to say! I was impressed with her call to target the males in the minority alliance because, she was right, they didn’t see it coming.


bradley

8. Bradley
red-arrow1

Lucky you! Michael had a 25% chance of playing his idol correctly and sending Bradley straight to the pre-jury trip. It didn’t happen, which means Bradley and his group of 5 still have the majority and they do look tight. Looks like we’ve got a new villain in town… none other than Captain Complainer. (Or how about Babysitter Bradley?)

sebastian

8. Sea Bass

He’s in the majority, but I can definitely see him being taken out Ozzy/Malcom style in the coming weeks.


wendell

9. Wendell
green-arrow1

It’s hard to tell if Wendell is in any immediate danger. Laurel sounds like she wants to move forward with him and Domenick though, so that’s obviously a good sign.

domenick

9. Domenick

He’s got an idol in his pocket and the legacy advantage. And while that legacy advantage is like TOTALLY CURSED, right??? I think he has a chance now that Laurel and Donathan have decided to join his squad.


jenna

10. Jenna
green-arrow3

The preview for next week is Jenna’s biggest selling point right now. If she’s about to link up with one of the core members of the majority alliance (the candyman himself), she’s got way more of an in than either Stephanie or Michael.

stephanie

10. Stephanie

She stood out a little too much this week and not in the best way. I think if Bradley’s “little alliance” maintains power, they might be coming for her next.


chelsea

11. Chelsea
green-arrow4

SHE SPOKE! WORDS!! “I’m sitting” would’ve been enough for me…. but then a whole confessional?! I’m so proud. I mean, she literally told us her group’s plan, which was then executed perfectly. Chelsea, a strategic legend in the making.

michael

11. Michael

LOVED the attempt this week. If only it worked! I wish I could rank him higher, but I’m really nervous for him moving forward because not only is he a stand out physical threat, he’s a strategic threat as well.


stephanie

12. Stephanie
minus

Just a little bit of hope (driskill) goes a long way. Seems like the Jenna/Sebastian connection gets rolling next week. If Sea Bass doesn’t mind a third wheel, maybe he spares Steph for another vote. If I was a casual, I’d feel like I’m supposed to be rooting for her, so I don’t think she’s being ripped away from us just yet?

bradley

12. Bradley

Might seem crazy that I’m ranking the leader of the majority alliance allllll the way down here, but he rubbed a lot of people the wrong way this week and if anyone decides to jump ship, he’s doomed.


domenick

13. Domenick
red-arrow2

Just like previous weeks, I’m worried Domenick may be giving up too much information. As I’ve mentioned, Laurel does seem interested in working with him over Chris. I just struggle to place Domenick very high because I think if one Jenga piece gets pulled out the wrong way, his game will come crumbling down.

desiree

13. Desiree

In her own words, “Awk-waaaard!” That’s all we heard from her this week. We almost got to hear from her one other time, but Michael had to cut her off. Not a good sign.


angela

14. Angela
green-arrow2

Not many people need a new swap as bad as Angela. I was hoping she would ditch Chris after he got back from Ghost Island, but I don’t think she plans on doing so.

jenna

14. Jenna

She’s in the minority alliance and we’re barely hearing from her, does not bode well moving forward.


michael

15. Michael
red-arrow6

Very impressed by your work this week! The obvious problem… it didn’t work. You lost your #1 ally, you have a big target on your back, and now you’re really down in numbers. Either go find James’ other idol, or dig deep and ensure your tribe wins immunity.

chris

15. Chris

Uh oh, this is baaaad. I don’t really see how he’s gonna get out of this one.


chris

16. Chris
minus

I’m not sure how much longer we can keep up the Chris and Dom storyline, so it has to be coming to an end soon, right? I’ve been waiting for Chris to reach peak Drew Christy, but he’s already passed Drew’s episode count, so maybe Chris is in fact going to reverse the curse of the Drew Christy game? Nah…

angela

16. Angela

It’s not looking good for Angela. She was viewed as disposable last week and is essentially Chris’s loyal henchman, not a good position to be in.

sgibar

Become a patron of RHAP